Levies
Sometimes copyright law requires levies, or taxes, on a particular technology in order to compensate copyright holders for infringement which is likely to occur using that technology and which (it's argued) is impossible or impractical to regulate any other way. Often, this approach is coupled with a compulsory license, or a rule saying that certain kinds of copying or other activity using equipment or media on which a levy has been paid will not be copyright infringement -- because copyright holders have already been compensated by the levy for that activity.
The most standard U.S. example is the Audio Home Recording Act, which provides for levies on certain technologies (defined as "Digital Audio Recording Media" (DARM) and "Digital Audio Recording Device" (DARD)); there is a corresponding rule that, roughly, the use of these technologies for home recording of copyrighted musical works is not an infringement of copyright. (That was likely true anyway under pre-existing copyright law, but AHRA at least clarifies this so people can have some certainty about it.)
I have right here a DARM on which I paid a levy (or at least on which somebody paid a levy, and the cost was certainly passed along to me) -- an MPO MiniDisc, which amusing advertises "Extra High Digital Grade" (as opposed to that low-quality digital recording regular MiniDiscs offer?).
These levies are unfair, because they punish everyone for some people's copyright infringement (and, in some sense, they punish all people who commit less-than-average amounts of copyright infringement as though they had committed an average amount of copyright infringement). In some cases, there might be no way to get out of a levy even by showing that a technology would be used for a strictly non-infringing purpose.
However, levies are an extremely interesting proposal to consider in contradistinction to harsh technology regulatory regimes advocated by some copyright holders. As most readers of this diary will be aware, some copyright holders have been advocating for years that technology which can likely be used to infringe copyrights (or which turn out to be used frequently to infringe copyrights) should be banned -- or be required by law to be redesigned in a way which would make them less useful for copyright infringement. (The part you don't hear about is that this always ends up making them less useful for other things, too.)
Those proposals are a particularly terrible thing,
I think the levy approach is inherently far less restrictive, because a levy need not be combined with a technology design mandate. (The AHRA levy was -- it's called SCMS, or Serial Copy Management System. SCMS has led to a pretty substantial dissatisfaction with AHRA-regulated DARMs.) You can say that something is subject to a tax without saying that it's illegal to sell it. And then people who want that thing can still purchase it, by paying the tax.
Under a mandate law like the CBDTPA, or other mandates like the broadcast flag mandate, the most functional technology, which I want most and which I think most technology users want most, is not legally available at any price. You can't say "Not only will I not infringe copyrights but I will pay the copyright industries $5,000 to compensate them for the infringement which they believe I will commit because they don't trust me"; no, there's no provision for doing that.
(The DMCA is the same way, even though the electronics industry doesn't call it a "mandate" because they haven't quite realized that trying to interoperate with something, or modify something, without permission from its manufacturer is virtuous and not vicious. Although maybe they're getting there [see "Oops"].)
European electronics industries are suggesting exactly the reverse, that DRM is better than levies. (To be fair, they're not necessarily facing legislative design mandates as urgently as are U.S. industries, so the "alternative" to levies which threatens the electronics industries there may be a simple boycott by the entertainment companies, and not legislative controls.)
I think this is silly when the alternative is a government technology mandate. In the DRM scenario, your equipment is broken and doesn't do what you want, and, if the DRM vendor has done a good job, you can't fix it. That's true whether the impetus for the DRM came from a mandate or from a desire to make publishers feel comfortable. In the levy scenario, you have to pay extra because you're being punished for someone else's infringing activity (or for your own infringing activity, if you are actually an infringer).
In the levy version, though, you have a choice about what to buy; you can buy regular fully-functional unrestricted equipment. There is still competition and there is still the possibility of getting technology which is user-serviceable (if the levy is unaccompanied by a "robustness" mandate). There is still the possibility of not having someone else decide which uses you can make, which attempts at interoperability will actually interoperate, which software you can write, etc. (Note to trusted computing advocates: I realize that you can write arbitrary software in a trusted computing environment. On the other hand, you couldn't necessarily write an arbitrary media player, not because you can't write the player itself but because you can't get your media in cleartext form into the particular virtual machine where your arbitrary media player is running.)
When I mentioned levies to some entertainment lawyers at BPDG, they tended to repeat the argument that levies are unfair, because you're being punished for what someone else is doing. I didn't know what to say. I wanted to say that the entire BPDG process, from beginning to end, was about punishing people for what someone else was doing. (Losing capabilities you otherwise would have had, against your will, is a punishment, isn't it?)
I can't understand how entertainment lawyers who are busy advocating for you not to be able to buy particular technologies at all think that it would be "unfair" for you instead to be taxed if you buy those technologies. Who's constraining consumer choice more here?
- Status quo. DRM equipment: legal, no tax. Non-DRM equipment: legal, no tax (except AHRA, DMCA, etc.).
- Mandate version. DRM equipment: legal, no tax. Non-DRM equipment: illegal.
- Levy version. DRM equipment: legal, no tax. Non-DRM equipment: legal, with a tax levied upon purchase.
If you used an international trade analogy, you could imagine advocates of banning something responding to a proposal to tax imports of it instead: "But tarriffs are unfair!". Granted.
Again, perhaps EICTA and other levy opponents who are DRM proponents are imagining a world in which DRM and non-DRM technologies compete freely (although I think really free competition would require obliterating anticircumvention rules). And in that vision, perhaps some publishers are distributing things in an encrypted form which they expect will work only with the DRM equipment.
So perhaps that's an artifact of a European climate in which levies are seen as a real political threat and tech mandates aren't.
- Links from other weblogs:
Mon Dec 21 21:10:37: Buy tadalafil prescription drug store online. from Buy tadalafil prescription drug store online.
Tadalafil no prescription. Buy tadalafil prescription drug store online.
Mon Dec 21 23:10:09: Buy carisoprodol online no prescription required. from Carisoprodol no prescription.
Buy carisoprodol online no prescription required. Carisoprodol no prescription.
Tue Dec 22 10:54:20: Buy valtrex without prescription. from Buy valtrex without prescription.
Buy valtrex without prescription.
Tue Dec 22 14:16:51: Tadalafil no prescription. from Tadalafil no prescription.
Buy tadalafil prescription drug store online.
Tue Dec 22 23:35:54: Buy alprazolam 2mg bars. from Buy alprazolam uk.
Buy alprazolam without prescription. Buy alprazolam. Buy alprazolam uk. Buy alprazolam 2mg bars.
Wed Dec 23 06:13:25: Lorazepam withdrawal. from Lorazepam.
Lorazepam side effects. Side effects of lorazepam. Lorazepam.
Wed Dec 23 14:18:27: Buy lorazepam. from Buy lorazepam.
Buy lorazepam.
Thu Dec 24 04:50:55: Percocet without prescription. from Percocet without prescription cheap.
Prescription percocet. Buy percocet without a prescription. Percocet no prescription. Buy percocet online no prescription. No prescription percocet.
Thu Dec 24 14:30:44: Butalbital no prescription. from Butalbital no prescription.
Butalbital no prescription.
Thu Dec 24 22:29:10: Buy oxycodone online without. from Buy oxycodone.
Buy oxycodone without prescription.
Fri Dec 25 02:08:41: Meridia. from C health meridia.
Does meridia really work. Meridia. Meridia diet index dietlist net.
Fri Dec 25 14:21:24: Adipex without a prescription. from Rx site no prior prescription adipex.
Adipex no prescription cod. Adipex no prescription. Adipex p free prescription. Adipex without prescription.
Fri Dec 25 23:45:05: Vicodin. from Vicodin.
How long does vicodin withdrawal last. Quiting vicodin information. Vicodin side effects. Vicodin. Detox vicodin. Is it safe to snort vicodin. Buy vicodin online without. Vicodin withdrawal. Vicodin no rx.
Sat Dec 26 11:06:41: Buy clonazepam online no prescription. from Clonazepam no prescription no membership.
Clonazepam overnight no prescription. Buy clonazepam online no prescription. Clonazepam no prescription.
Sat Dec 26 15:10:55: Buy oxycodone without prescription. from Buy oxycodone.
Buy oxycodone without prescription. Buy oxycodone. Buy oxycodone online without.
Sun Dec 27 01:19:04: Can viagra causes legs to ache. from Viagra.
Viagra. Buy generic viagra.
Sun Dec 27 15:21:38: Butalbital no prescription. from Butalbital no prescription.
Butalbital no prescription.
Mon Jan 04 00:14:03: Adipex p free prescription. from Adipex without a prescription.
Adipex without a prescription.
Mon Jan 04 06:22:06: Vicodin without prescription. from Vicodin xanax no prescription.
Buy vicodin without prescription. No prior prescription vicodin. Vicodin without prescription. Vicodin without a prescription. Buy vicodin online without a prescription. Lortab vicodin no prescription needed.
Mon Jan 04 07:59:06: Buy oxycodone without prescription. from Oxycodone online without a prescription.
Online prescription oxycodone. Buy oxycodone without prescription. Oxycodone no prescription. Buy oxycodone without a prescription. Oxycodone prescription.
Mon Jan 04 09:43:35: Butalbital no prescription. from Butalbital no prescription.
Butalbital no prescription.
Mon Jan 04 18:52:20: Buy oxycodone. from Buy oxycodone without a prescription.
Buy oxycodone online. Buy oxycodone without prescription. Buy oxycodone without a prescription.
Tue Jan 05 05:37:10: Cheap fioricet and one day delivery. from Cheap fioricet and one day delivery.
Cheap fioricet and one day delivery. Fioricet cheap. Cheap fioricet.
Tue Jan 05 19:02:59: Fioricet prescription. from Buy fioricet online without a prescription.
Fioricet prescription. Fioricet info pain medication prescription. Fioricet without prescription. Buy fioricet online without a prescription.
Wed Jan 06 06:41:53: Cheap lortab online. from Lortab for cheap.
Lortab 10mg 500. Lortab 7.5. Lortab.
Wed Jan 06 20:16:08: Buy oxycodone. from Buy oxycodone.
Buy oxycodone online. Buy oxycodone without prescription. Buy oxycodone. Buy oxycodone without a prescription.
Thu Jan 07 10:17:43: Xanax. from Order xanax online.
Xanax bars. Buy xanax. Xanax. Xanax without a prescription.
Thu Jan 07 15:35:26: Adipex phentermine vs. from Adipex p free prescription.
Adipex. Adipex p. Adipex no prescription. Adipex phentermine online pharmacy.
Fri Jan 08 00:07:12: Zolpidem without prescription. from Zolpidem no prescription.
Zolpidem without prescription.
Fri Jan 08 00:35:40: Is oxycodone or hydrocodone stronger. from Hydrocodone.
Hydrocodone no prescription. Hydrocodone detection period. I had a healthy baby while i took hydrocodone. Snorting hydrocodone. How to ween off hydrocodone while pregnant.
Fri Jan 08 11:11:45: Butalbital. from Butalbital 50.00 90 tabs free shipping.
Butalbital overdose. Butalbital.
Fri Jan 08 14:04:18: Tramadol. from Tramadol.
Tramadol.
Sat Jan 09 01:06:22: Carisoprodol phentermine yellow all on one site. from Pharmacy online carisoprodol description price.
Carbamazepine carisoprodol pharmacy drugs.
Sat Jan 09 04:24:54: Buy lortab. from Buy lortab.
Buy lortab.
Sat Jan 09 13:13:06: Buy fioricet. from Buy fioricet.
Buy fioricet bloghoster. Buy fioricet online that ships to missouri. Buy fioricet. Buy fioricet full information amp low prices.
Sun Jan 10 00:06:02: Buy cheap tramadol mg tablets only in us online. from Cheap tramadol platinum rx.
Cheap tramadol. Tramadol cheap no rx free from india. Tramadol cheap. Cheap tramadol fedex overnight.
Sun Jan 10 04:03:17: Crushing muscle relaxer soma. from Soma review the retail church chris thron.
Soma without prescription. Soma online sales. Soma. Watson soma. Prozac soma zoloft prozac onlineprescription.md.
Sun Jan 10 14:11:12: Buy adipex cheap and fast. from Buy adipex online.
Buy adipex online without prescription. Buying adipex online without a prescription. Buy adipex without prescription. Buy adipex online. Buy adipex without a prescription. Buy prescription adipex online. Buy cheap adipex.
Sun Jan 10 23:50:42: Extract codeine. from How codeine effects the brain.
Cheap codeine no prescription. Acetaminophen codeine phosphate. Codeine. Codeine withdrawal. Codeine dose. Guaifenesin codeine.
Mon Jan 11 14:04:23: Amoxicillin. from Are greyhounds allergic to amoxicillin.
Amoxicillin. Amoxicillin side effects. Amoxicillin blood sugar.
Mon Jan 11 21:30:00: Pics of lortab 10 750. from Lortab.
Lortab dosages. Lortab 10mg 500. Effects of lortab. Buy lortab. Lortab. Snorting lortab. Findpills net search results lortab.
Tue Jan 12 00:10:01: Recreational viagra. from Buy viagra uk.
Viagra. Generic viagra. Free viagra.
Tue Jan 12 06:09:51: Cheapest viagra prices. from Free viagra sample.
Viagra. Impulse female viagra. Order viagra online. Generic viagra. Viagra uk. Viagra prices. Buy viagra uk.
Tue Jan 12 06:13:47: Phentermine no prescription. from Phentermine no prescription.
Phentermine no prescription. Phentermine prescription. No prescription phentermine. Buy no phentermine prescription.
Wed Jan 13 00:42:49: Buy adderall cheap. from Buy cheap adderall online.
Buy cheap adderall online. Cheap adderall.
Wed Jan 13 06:15:48: Tramadol no prescription. from Tramadol no prescription pharmacy discounter.
Tramadol prescription. Tramadol no prescription. Tramadol without prescription. Does tramadol require a prescription in mexico. Generic for tramadol prescription. Tramadol no prescription pharmacy discounter.
Wed Jan 13 10:15:45: Buying carisoprodol. from Carisoprodol phentermine yellow.
Carisoprodol. Carisoprodol phentermine yellow.
Wed Jan 13 19:53:36: Buy vicodin online without. from Vicodin withdrawl.
Addiction vicodin. Vicodin. Vicodin without prescription. Order vicodin es generic.
Wed Jan 13 20:07:36: Phentermine without prescription. from Phentermine 37.5 no prescription needed.
No prescription phentermine. Phentermine no prescription necessary.
Wed Jan 13 21:43:54: Buy oxycodone online without. from Buy oxycodone.
Buy oxycodone without prescription. Buy oxycodone.
Thu Jan 14 08:34:08: Butalbital. from Butalbital apap caffeine.
Butalbital. Butalbital order. Butalbital medical license.
Thu Jan 14 09:57:28: Buy adderall. from Buy adderall without a prescription.
Buy adderall. Buy adderall without a prescription. Where can i buy adderall online. Buy adderall no prescription.
Thu Jan 14 16:37:37: Purchase butalbital with no prescription. from Butalbital codeine no prescription.
Order butalbital overnight no prescription.
Thu Jan 14 20:06:53: Cheap phentermine. from Cheap phentermine free shipping.
Cheap phentermine. Cheap phentermine no prescription. Phentermine cheap. Buy cheap phentermine. Buy phentermine order cheap online.
Fri Jan 15 04:15:51: Buy carisoprodol. from Buy carisoprodol.
Buy carisoprodol. Buy carisoprodol online no prescription.
Fri Jan 15 08:37:46: Buy alprazolam uk. from Buy alprazolam 2mg bars.
Buy alprazolam without prescription. Buy alprazolam. Buy alprazolam 2mg bars. Buy alprazolam uk.
Fri Jan 15 09:55:02: Buy adderall. from Doctors adderall.
Adderall alcohol. Snorting adderall effects. Adderall. Adderall in mexico. Adderall without a prescription.
Fri Jan 15 20:08:00: Adipex buy adipex online goshen. from Buy cheap adipex with cash on delivery.
Buy adipex. Buy adipex p online forum. Buy adipex best prices fast shipping. Buy adipex cod.
Fri Jan 15 21:05:44: Butalbital no prescription. from Butalbital no prescription.
Butalbital no prescription.
Sat Jan 16 08:18:04: Butalbital order. from Butalbital.
Fiorinal butalbital aspirin caffeine for migraines. Butalbital. Butalbital medical license.
Sat Jan 16 09:24:54: Alprazolam no prescription. from Alprazolam no prescription.
Alprazolam without prescription. Alprazolam no prescription.
Sat Jan 16 09:53:19: Re viagra cello. from Viagra.
Viagra on line.
Sat Jan 16 18:15:13: Buy oxycodone online. from Buy oxycodone.
Buy oxycodone.
Sat Jan 16 19:04:47: Hydrocodone drug testing. from Hydrocodone extraction.
Hydrocodone. Opana same pleasurable effects hydrocodone. Hydrocodone apap 5 500. Ic hydrocodone apap 5 500.
Sun Jan 17 04:14:39: Lortab prescription online. from Lortab online.
Buy lortab.
Sun Jan 17 04:37:52: Carisoprodol pharmacy. from Carisoprodol.
Carisoprodol mg right place for it carisoprodol mg. Carisoprodol fedex cod. Somas with carisoprodol doese t containt codine. Carisoprodol. Buy carisoprodol online lowest price guarantee. Carisoprodol phentermine yellow.
Mon Jan 18 02:10:16: Buy phentermine. from Buy phentermine.
Buy phentermine.
Mon Jan 18 08:29:44: Ephedrine no prescription. from Ephedrine no prescription.
Ephedrine no prescription.
Mon Jan 18 17:55:49: Snorting adderall. from Adderall xr price.
Adderall prescription. Adderall.
Tue Jan 19 03:21:31: Buy ambien online cod. from Buy ambien.
Buy ambien without a prescription. Buy ambien with a discount at leading pharmacy. Buy ambien drug online. Buy ambien overnight mail md consultation. Buy ambien.
Tue Jan 19 05:26:21: Soma and addiction. from Soma.
Diabetes one and soma. Soma without prescription. Soma sun pilates. Soma. Soma sen arizona. Drug soma.
Tue Jan 19 20:16:22: Diazepam drug. from Diazepam peak effect.
Pharmacy buy diazepam. Valium diazepam. Diazepam on your liver. Diazepam.
Wed Jan 20 05:45:05: Alprazolam. from Alprazolam no prescription.
Alprazolam. Mylan alprazolam. I need alprazolam. Cheap 2mg alprazolam. Alprazolam er. Alprazolam po box fedex overnight.
Thu Jan 21 02:19:38: Buy cheap valium. from Buy cheap valium.
Buy valium online. Buy valium. Buy valium no prescription. Buy valium without prescription. Buy buy casino link valium. Buy cheap valium.
Thu Jan 21 08:57:03: Pain management orlando oxycontin. from Oxycontin injury lawyer columbus.
Oxycontin online. Connecticut oxycontin attorneys. Hartford oxycontin lawyers. Oxycontin crush. Oxycontin addiction. Connecticut oxycontin lawyers.
Thu Jan 21 11:45:55: Buy vicodin no prescription. from Buy vicodin no prescription.
Buy vicodin online no prescription. Buy vicodin no prescription. Buy vicodin.
Thu Jan 21 21:50:54: Buy valium. from Buy valium pay cod overnight delivery.
Buy valium with mastercard. Buy valium c.o.d.. Buy valium. Buy valium without a prescription. Buy valium pay cod overnight delivery. Beamto buy link online valium pharmacy forum. Buy valium online.
Fri Jan 22 02:22:53: Buy cheap oxycontin. from Buy oxycontin pills.
Buy oxycontin. Buy oxycontin online. Buy cheap oxycontin. Where to buy oxycontin.
Fri Jan 22 23:06:03: Ultram tramadol. from Tramadol.
Tramadol. What is tramadol. How much tramadol for daily use for dogs. Tramadol c.o.d delivery.
Sat Jan 23 05:10:48: Alprazolam. from I need alprazolam.
Alprazolam online. Alprazolam for dogs. Alprazolam no prescription. Alprazolam. I need alprazolam.
Sat Jan 23 09:02:00: Buy soma from canada. from Buy soma online without rx.
Buy soma cod. Buy cheap soma. Buy soma online. Buy soma bloghoster. Http pills.viptemplates.com p buy soma.
Sat Jan 23 18:44:41: Terbinafine hydrochloride generic. from Can i donate blood while taking terbinafine.
Terbinafine candidiasis.
Sat Jan 23 23:48:14: Tramadol hcl. from Tramadol side effects.
Buy tramadol. Tramadol.
Sun Jan 24 00:40:38: Pseudoephedrine with codeine cough syrup. from Codeine.
Pseudoephedrine with codeine cough syrup. Cocaine and codeine. Codeine as antitussive. Codeine combined pseudoephedrine. Codeine. Phenergan and codeine. Buy 222 codeine. Codeine online.
Sun Jan 24 11:07:13: Buy ativan fed ex no prescription. from Buy ativan online.
Buy ativan online order ativan online. Ativan -buy -buying -online -cheap. Buy ativan fed ex no prescription. Buy ativan online free usa dr consultation. Buy ativan online from discount pharmacy store. Buy ativan no prescription.
Mon Jan 25 05:24:55: Meridia reviews. from Meridia coupon.
Meridia.
Mon Jan 25 05:47:49: Adderall. from Buy adderall without a prescription.
Buy adderall without a prescription. Adderall without prescription. Adderall purchase without prescription. Adderall. Safely withdrawing from adderall. Generic adderall.
Mon Jan 25 18:06:04: Buy phentermine now cheapest price. from Buy cheap phentermine.
Buy phentermine. Buy cheap online phentermine. Buy phentermine online without prescription cheap. Buy phentermine on line. Buy no phentermine prescription. Buy phentermine order cheap online. Buy cheap phentermine. Buy phentermine online c.o.d..
Mon Jan 25 22:28:04: Levothyroxine 150 mcg. from Levothyroxine sodium for dogs.
Levoxyl vs levothyroxine. Levothyroxine. Levothyroxine 575 mg.
Tue Jan 26 04:13:01: Buy phentermine online. from Buy cheap online phentermine.
Buy phentermine. Buy c 20heap phentermine online. Buy cialis phentermine. Buy cheap phentermine online. Buy phentermine buy. Buy ph... phentermine 37 url.
Tue Jan 26 09:06:31: Ativan. from Ativan.
Ativan treatmenr for seizures. Ativan lorazepam. Ativan withdrawal. Ativan *nesta. Ativan.
Tue Jan 26 20:13:10: Hydrocodone. from Hydrocodone.
Hydrocodone. Online prescription for hydrocodone.
Wed Jan 27 03:27:10: Buy vicodin without script. from Buy vicodin without script.
Buy vicodin without a prescription.
Wed Jan 27 06:56:09: Buy hydrocodone without a prescription. from Buy hydrocodone without prescription.
Buy hydrocodone online. Buy hydrocodone online without a prescription. Buy hydrocodone without a prescription.
Thu Jan 28 02:48:27: Buy lorazepam. from Buy lorazepam.
Buy lorazepam.
Thu Jan 28 02:59:46: Adderall coupon. from Adderall.
Adderall 7.5. Adderall. Adderall and migraines. Ordering adderall. Where to buy adderall.
Thu Jan 28 21:39:32: Changes ephedrine causes in the body. from Who sells ephedrine diet pills.
Ephedrine.
Thu Jan 28 21:50:14: Adderall side effects. from Adderall.
Adderall xr side effects. Buy wholesale adderall. Buy adderall no prescription. Adderall. Snorting adderall.
Fri Jan 29 11:19:13: Prescriptions that contain ephedrine. from Baseball player dies from ephedrine.
Ephedrine faq ephedrine fatloss. Vasopro ephedrine. Ephedrine weight loss products. Extract ephedrine. Health risks of ephedrine. Addiction to ephedrine.
Fri Jan 29 20:40:34: Buy tramadol. from Buy tramadol.
Where buy tramadol click here. Buy tramadol american express. Buy tramadol in the united states. Buy tramadol the lowest prices chtiblog com. Buy tramadol. Tramadol buy.
Fri Jan 29 23:05:00: Ephedrine to buy. from Ephedrine faq.
Vaspro ephedrine.
Sat Jan 30 06:58:30: Pictures of oxycontin addicts. from Oxycontin lawyer cleveland.
Oxycontin side effects. Oxycontin.
Sat Jan 30 08:51:34: Alprazolam. from Alprazolam r039 prices.
Alprazolam from mexico. Alprazolam.
Sat Jan 30 17:48:52: Buy hydrocodone. from Buy hydrocodone.
Buy hydrocodone.
Sun Jan 31 00:46:56: Purchase alprazolam online. from Alprazolam no prescription.
Info about alprazolam. Alprazolam.
Sun Jan 31 04:35:43: Buy hydrocodone without a prescription. from Buy hydrocodone with no rx.
Buy hydrocodone online consultation. Buy hydrocodone.
Sun Jan 31 10:31:31: Buy vicodin online without. from Buy vicodin no prescription.
Buy vicodin online no prescription. Buy vicodin.
Sun Jan 31 22:39:13: Buy hydrocodone. from Buy hydrocodone.
Buy hydrocodone.
Sun Jan 31 23:34:46: Buy 180 xanax. from Buy xanax mastercard overnight delivery.
Buy 180 xanax 2mg. Buy xanax. Buy 180 xanax. Buy xanax online without a prescription. Buy cheap xanax without prescription.
Mon Feb 01 11:11:10: Buy hydrocodone. from Buy hydrocodone.
Buy hydrocodone.
Mon Feb 01 11:24:11: Butalbital. from Generic butalbital.
Butalbital. Cheap butalbital. Butalbital order. Butalbital suspension license. Ic butalbital compound.
Mon Feb 01 12:26:59: Fioricet cheap. from Fioricet cheap.
Fioricet cheap. Cheap fioricet.
Mon Feb 01 18:49:36: No quarter is max boot using oxycontin. from Where to buy oxycontin.
Oxycontin addiction. Buy oxycontin. Oxycontin.
Tue Feb 02 03:36:53: Tramadol. from Tramadol.
Buy tramadol. Tramadol withdraw. Tramadol. Hydrochloride tramadol. Tramadol cheap no rx.
Tue Feb 02 03:49:38: Buy online cheap and fast tramadol. from Buy cheap tramadol tramadol mg quick delivery cod.
Buy tramadol online save wholesale price yep. Activado agcode buy tramadol icqwebmail info. Buy tramadol. Buy online cheap and fast tramadol. Buy cheap tramadol mg tablets only in us online. Buy tramadol online best prices limited time off.
Tue Feb 02 22:29:03: Ativan. from Lorazepam ativan pharmacology healthyplace com.
Ativan information. Ativan side effects. Ativan what is it used for. Lorazepam ativan information and resources. Can you give ativan to a dog. Ativan. Ativan vs xanax.
Tue Feb 02 22:40:36: Buy fioricet. from Buy fioricet.
Buy fioricet.
Wed Feb 03 12:49:13: Oxycodone addiction. from Oxycodone addiction.
Oxycodone.
Wed Feb 03 17:51:28: Vicodin detox. from Cheap vicodin cod.
Vicodin. Buying cod vicodin. Buy vicodin.
Wed Feb 03 18:02:34: Buy 180 xanax. from Buy cheap xanax without prescription.
Buy xanax. Buy cheap generic xanax.
Thu Feb 04 05:54:55: Generic percocet. from Percocet.
Percocet. Percocet 93-490 10 mg. How to extract acitaminiaphine from percocet.
Thu Feb 04 06:01:30: Buy tramadol. from Buy tramadol.
Buy tramadol.
Thu Feb 04 17:07:08: Xanax. from Generic xanax no prescription.
Lethal blood levels of xanax. Xanax without prescription. Xanax. Buy xanax online. Xanax effect. Xanax bars.
Thu Feb 04 17:56:17: Buy tramadol. from Buy tramadol.
Buy tramadol online save wholesale price yep. Buy tramadol.
Fri Feb 05 00:35:12: Penicillin vk vs amoxicillin. from Side effects of amoxicillin.
Increasing amoxicillin dosage during. Reaction of amoxicillin.
Fri Feb 05 01:34:53: Adderall. from Buy adderall without a prescription.
Adderall. Taking adderall.
Fri Feb 05 02:09:10: Buy vicodin without script. from Buy vicodin online next day delivery.
Buy vicodin online next day delivery. Buy vicodin no prescription.
Fri Feb 05 11:37:17: Fioricet c.o.d.. from Fioricet.
Fioricet. Fioricet free shipping. Cheapest fioricet. Fioricet phentermine shipping.
Sat Feb 06 00:44:04: Buy oxycontin pills. from Buy cheap oxycontin.
Buy oxycontin. Buy oxycontin online. Buy oxycontin pills.
Sat Feb 06 00:54:49: Discount meridia. from Buy meridia.
Buy meridia. Discount meridia. Pillinc buy phentermine adipex meridia online. Meridia. Where to buy meridia. Meridia and wellbutrin.
Sat Feb 06 02:51:40: Tadalafil and proscar propecia success. from Tadalafil.
Tadalafil. Buy tadalafil.
Sat Feb 06 16:48:37: Adderall. from Buy adderall without a prescription.
Inject adderall. Buy adderall without a prescription. Adderall without a precscription. Adderall. Kidney pain and adderall. Order didrex adderall no prescription.
Sat Feb 06 18:31:11: Xanax bars. from Xanax withdrawal symptom.
Xanax.
Sun Feb 07 00:58:14: Buy tadalafil. from Tadalafil and proscar propecia success.
Buy tadalafil. Tadalafil fedex. Tadalafil 10mg. Tadalafil. Sanafi tadalafil. Buy tadalafil 20mg.
Sun Feb 07 02:16:05: Viagra. from Discount viagra.
Viagra. Cheap viagra. Viagra side effects. Free sample of viagra. Free viagra. Viagra marketing. Cheapest viagra prices.
Sun Feb 07 04:21:50: Buy hydrocodone. from Buy hydrocodone.
Buy hydrocodone.
Sun Feb 07 20:01:47: Buy vicodin. from Buy vicodin.
Buy vicodin.
Sun Feb 07 21:33:22: Lortab. from Lortab.
How to snort lortab. All about lortab. Lortab online pharmacy. Lortab.
Mon Feb 08 05:19:19: Picture of tramadol 93. from Tramadol ultram medicine.
Low price tramadol. Tramadol. Ultram tramadol. Tramadol 100mg.
Mon Feb 08 07:36:59: Hydrocodone cough syrup. from Effects of hydrocodone.
Buy hydrocodone with no rx. Hydrocodone. Buy hydrocodone online. How long does hydrocodone stay in your system. Buy hydrocodone.
Wed Feb 10 05:10:21: Ambien hallucinations dizziness. from Ambien cr addiction.
Buy ambien 10. Ambien. Ambien addiction.
Wed Feb 10 05:17:32: Generic fioricet online. from Fioricet and blood work.
Fioricet. Fioricet online.
Wed Feb 10 19:54:39: Buy tramadol. from Buy tramadol.
Buy tramadol.
Wed Feb 10 21:46:00: Generic tadalafil u s supplier. from Tadalafil.
Tadalafil fedex. Tadalafil and proscar propecia success. Tadalafil.
Thu Feb 11 05:45:15: Buy oxycodone without a perscription. from Buy oxycodone.
Buy oxycodone hydrochloride. Oxycodone hydrocodone to buy. Buy oxycodone. Buy oxycodone no prescription.
Thu Feb 11 09:16:49: Clonazepam. from Clonazepam no prescription.
Order clonazepam cheap online. Clonazepam buy. Clonazepam.
Thu Feb 11 15:52:13: Tadalafil. from Tadalafil.
Buy tadalafil. Micronized tadalafil. Cialis tadalafil. Tadalafil. Cialis generic tadalafil. Cheapest tadalafil.
Thu Feb 11 17:06:44: Buy tramadol. from Buy tramadol.
Buy tramadol.
Fri Feb 12 03:10:05: Soma. from Soma to florida.
Soma radio. Soma cube. Soma to florida. Soma. Soma drug testing.
Fri Feb 12 05:49:07: Buy oxycodone. from Buy oxycodone.
Buy oxycodone.
Fri Feb 12 16:18:00: Tramadol for dogs. from Buy tramadol.
Hydrochloride tramadol. Buy tramadol. Drug encyclopedia cor 127 tramadol. Tramadol medication. Tramadol.
Fri Feb 12 17:30:31: Diazepam buy diazepam buy diazepam online pharmacy. from Diazepam buy diazepam buy diazepam online pharmacy.
Buy diazepam news.
Sat Feb 13 02:48:00: Cheap fioricet 32. from Cheap fioricet.
Cheap online fioricet. Cheap fioricet.
Sat Feb 13 05:33:05: Buy ativan. from Buy ativan.
Buy ativan.
Sat Feb 13 12:07:53: Buy phentermine online. from Buy phentermine online.
Buy phentermine hcl. Buy phentermine online no script. Buy phentermine no prescriptions. Buy phentermine online with e check. Buy phentermine online. Buy phentermine cod. Buy phentermine.
Sat Feb 13 19:07:33: Buy cheap viagra. from Buy viagra online.
Buy viagra online. Buy viagra ups. Buy viagra. Buy viagra online 35008. Buy viagra australia. Buy generic viagra.
Sat Feb 13 22:07:34: Buy fioricet. from Buy fioricet online that ships to missouri.
Buy fioricet bloghoster. Buy fioricet online that ships to missouri. Buy fioricet. Buy fioricet full information amp low prices.
Sun Feb 14 05:26:46: Buy amoxicillin. from Kids and 250 mg amoxicillin.
What is amoxicillin used for. Cat reactions to amoxicillin.
Sun Feb 14 07:10:18: Buy tramadol online cod. from Buy tramadol.
Buy tramadol.
Sun Feb 14 22:38:28: Buy oxycodone online without. from Buy oxycodone online without.
Buy oxycodone online. Buy oxycodone without prescription. Buy oxycodone.
Mon Feb 15 01:16:14: Buy fioricet online that ships to missouri. from Buy fioricet.
Buy fioricet online that ships to missouri.
Mon Feb 15 10:01:46: Buy vicodin without prescription. from Forum vicodin buy vicodin online.
Buy vicodin now. Buy vicodin online without a prescription. Buy vicodin without a prescription. Buy vicodin without script. Buy vicodin.
Mon Feb 15 19:12:42: Soma triathlon. from Drug soma.
Soma next day delievery. Soma compound. Soma. Soma next day.
Mon Feb 15 20:09:53: Buy oxycontin. from Buy oxycontin.
Buy oxycontin.
Tue Feb 16 05:25:23: Alprazolam and alcohol. from Alprazolam.
Alprazolam from mexico. Alprazolam-ratiopharm. Alprazolam synthesis. Buy alprazolam 2mg bars. Alprazolam.
Tue Feb 16 19:09:48: Buy oxycodone online without. from Delirium elderly oxycodone.
Oxycodone without prescription. Free oxycodone. Oxycodone reactions. Oxycodone controlled releasse. Snorting oxycodone. Oxycodone.
Wed Feb 17 05:01:13: Menstrual irregularity with levothyroxine. from Levothyroxine hyperphagia.
Levoxyl vs levothyroxine. Levothyroxine. Levothyroxine too much. Levothyroxine altrenitive.
Wed Feb 17 18:19:55: Buying lortab. from Lortab.
Lortab. Lortab without perscription. Buy lortab. Lortab 35 94.
Thu Feb 18 16:43:59: Alprazolam no prescription. from Alprazolam.
Alprazolam wikipedia the free encyclopedia. Alprazolam no prescription. Alprazolam intoxicated driving. Alprazolam.
