Möbius strip area
Jonathan Walther wrote to ask me an interesting question about the area of a Möbius strip.
I've been having a debate with a friend about how to calculate the area of a moebius strip, where the moebius strip is constructed by taking a 1" by 10" area, twisting it, and joining the ends.I have been maintaining that the area remains the same; that is, 10 square inches. My friend insists it is 20 square inches.
After discussion with my friend it became apparent that our different calculations came from our having different concepts of "area". He used a strip of paper to "illustrate" the moebius strip, and I feel this gave him erroneous intuition in this case.
My observation was that if you did make the strip from paper, you would need 20 sq. in. of paint in order to paint the whole thing. If you used 10 sq. in. of paint, you would have 10 sq. in. of surface unpainted.
However, Jonathan argues that this is a misinterpretation if the Möbius strip is seen as having zero thickness, because then points on one "side" are actually identical with the corresponding points on the "other side". He suggests that, on a zero-thickness strip, you can go only 10" before you return to your starting point. (On a strip made of paper with non-zero thickness, you must go 20" before returning to your starting point.)
Does anybody have a view to clarify this? It does just seem like a question of how to define surface area, but maybe there is a particular definition of "surface area" or "Möbius strip" which is somehow preferable.
(Normally you deal with areas in a plane, and the definition is easier. Is there something handy from multivariate calculus here?)
- Links from other weblogs:
Sat Nov 15 09:17:50: Calico film music design free gay video chat guys. from Free gay chat with video.
Free gay chat with video. Free gay video chat. Live gay live gay sex free gay live video sex chat.
Sat Nov 15 16:20:22: Free poker softwear. from Free poker.
Free poker tournaments. Free online strip poker xxx. Free poker online.
Sun Nov 16 01:06:45: Strip poker free. from Free online strip poker.
10 player poker table top free shipping. Free online poker. Free poker downloads. Free poker softwear. Free poker. Free poker money. Free strip poker.
Sun Nov 16 09:56:58: Tramadol. from Tramadol.
Tramadol. Tramadol ultam. Tramadol 100mg.
Mon Nov 17 12:30:50: Australia poker. from Highest poker australia.
Highest poker australia.
Tue Nov 18 04:46:46: College loan. from College loan.
College loan.
Tue Nov 18 22:29:05: Free strip poker. from Free poker tournaments.
Free poker.net. Free poker games. Free poker. Free poker tournament. Free poker bot. Play free strip poker game now. Free online strip poker. Free strip poker.
Wed Nov 19 12:51:21: Cheap flights to paris from phl. from Athens to paris cheap flights.
Athens to paris cheap flights.
Thu Nov 20 03:11:32: Order hydrocodone. from Order hydrocodone.
Order hydrocodone.
Fri Nov 21 07:30:23: Payday loan online. from Payday loan online.
Payday loan online. Online payday loan.
Fri Nov 21 08:55:37: Free poker tournament. from Free online strip poker..
10 player poker table top free shipping. Free video strip poker. Free online poker. Free poker. Free online poker games.
Sat Nov 22 15:03:52: Phentermine no prescription. from Phentermine no prescription.
Phentermine prescription online.
Sun Nov 23 18:46:44: Payday loan online. from Online payday loan.
Advance cash fast loan online payday quick. Payday loan online. The most respected online payday loan company. American online marketing payday loan.
Mon Nov 24 04:12:24: Cheap flights paris. from Athens to paris cheap flights.
Cheap flights paris. Cheap flights to paris from phl. Athens to paris cheap flights.
Mon Nov 24 14:12:02: Cheap flights. from Cheap flights.
Cheap flights canada. Cheap flights. Cheap flights to las vegas nevada tripadvisor. Cheap flights to vegas.
Mon Nov 24 14:32:23: Bad cash credit loan payday. from Bad cash credit fast loan payday.
Bad cash credit fast loan payday.
Mon Nov 24 22:54:52: Online casino gambling and online slots guide. from Online casino gambling poker slots roulette win.
Online gambling casino. Online casino gambling reviews of best casinos. Online gambling and casino reviews. Online game gambling casino. Gambling casino online.
Tue Nov 25 14:33:09: Phentermine no prescription. from Phentermine online no prescription.
Phentermine without a prescription. Phentermine 37.5 mg online prescription. No prescription phentermine. Phentermine without prescription. Phentermine no prescription. Buy no phentermine prescription.
Tue Nov 25 22:59:31: Phentermine online. from Phentermine prescription online.
Online consultation phentermine. Cheap phentermine online.
Wed Nov 26 19:46:22: Cheap airplane flights. from Cheap flights fiji.
Cheap flights to las vegas. Cheap flights canada. Cheap flights. Cheap international flights. Cheap british airways flights in uk. Cheap plane flights.
Thu Nov 27 10:25:32: Buy phentermine without a prescription. from Buy cheap phentermine onli ne.
Mg buy phentermine. Phentermine for sale best buy.
Fri Nov 28 02:51:08: Brand ultram order ultram tramadol pain medicine. from Brand ultram order ultram tramadol pain medicine.
Phendimetrazine order phentermine adipex tramadol. Order tramadol.
Sat Nov 29 10:00:27: Bad cash credit fast loan payday. from Bad cash credit fast loan payday.
Bad cash credit fast loan payday. Bad cash credit loan payday.
Mon Dec 01 17:43:07: Tramadol abuse pharmacy discounter. from Buy tramadol online save wholesale price yep.
Tramadol no rx 180 pills.
Fri Dec 05 20:45:02: Best online casino. from Best online casino.
Best online casino.
Sat Dec 06 20:19:49: Cheap air flights. from Cheap flights.
Cheap flights. Cheap flights to dublin. Cheap flights to pa.
Sun Dec 07 18:52:08: Best casinos guide. from Online casino guide and online casinos news.
Aicpa industry audit guide on casinos. Casinos aicpa audit and accounting guide. Miami south florida casinos aol city guide. Online casino guide and online casinos news. Bigcasinolist com a world guide to casinos.
Mon Dec 08 03:58:55: Phentermine online. from Cheapest phentermine online.
Buy phentermine online. Adipexdrug addiction order phentermine online. Online phentermine.
Mon Dec 08 04:23:39: Phentermine discount phentermine dpill com. from Discount phentermine.
Discount phentermine.
Mon Dec 08 13:00:26: Online casino slots. from Online casino games.
Online casino games. Platinum play online casino. Free online casino bonuses. Online casino reviews. Online casino promotions. Free online casino. Online casino.
Mon Dec 08 23:27:00: Great free ringtone sites. from Free prelude final fantasy ringtone.
Cingular free motorola ringtone. Animal ringtone free download. Free driver usb cable ringtone program. Free verizon ringtone download. Free ringtone download. Free ringtone bagpipe.
Tue Dec 09 08:12:39: Valium prescription online. from Buy valium online without a prescription.
Buy valium online.
Tue Dec 09 17:59:38: Nexium. from Nexium generic.
Nexium side effects. Nexium cholesterol medicine. What is nexium 40mg use for. Nexium.
Wed Dec 10 02:42:34: Ephedra. from Ephedra.
Colorado ephedra lawyer. Thermogen ephedra. Ephedra.
Wed Dec 10 11:19:38: Cheap flights paris. from Cheap flights paris.
Cheap flights paris.
Wed Dec 10 20:07:05: Stores that carry ephedra diet products. from Ephedra diet pills.
Black ice ephedra. Stores that carry ephedra diet products. Ephedra.
Thu Dec 11 04:50:12: Casino royale. from Casino royale reviews.
Mystic lake casino.
Thu Dec 11 16:37:58: Tramadol no prescription pharmacy discounter. from Tramadol without prescription.
Tramadol non prescription over the counter. Generic for tramadol prescription. Tramadol prescription.
Thu Dec 11 18:23:19: Free mobile phone polyphonic ringtone top sites. from Free midi ringtone somebody watching me.
Free ringtone downloads. How can i make my own free ringtone.
Fri Dec 12 03:07:16: Casino royale. from Casino royal.
Casino royale. Casino royale cast. Free casino. Casino royal.
Fri Dec 12 15:05:36: Payday loans. from Payday loans.
Payday loans. Payday loans fast. No fax payday loans. Holiday payday loans. Help for people in trouble with payday loans.
Sat Dec 13 00:28:35: Phendimetrazine order phentermine adipex tramadol. from Phendimetrazine order phentermine adipex tramadol.
Brand ultram order ultram tramadol pain medicine.
Sat Dec 13 14:13:13: Amoxicillin expiry. from Amoxicillin orange suspension.
Identify amoxicillin 500 tab. Are greyhounds allergic to amoxicillin. Amoxicillin and strep b. Amoxicillin soar throat.
Sat Dec 13 15:30:19: Difference between percocet and ultracet. from Side effects of percocet.
Percocet 93-490. Buy percocet. Percocet high blood pressure. Cheap percocet. How do i get off percocet. Buy tylox percocet. Percocet shipped cod no prior. How long is percocet in your system.
Sun Dec 14 01:08:43: Percocet for anxiety. from Percocet.
Long term use of percocet. Percocet.
Sun Dec 14 14:27:03: Percocet. from Percocet.
Symtoms of withdrawl from percocet. Will percocet show up in a drug test. Dosages for percocet. Percocet without prescription. Percocet.
Sun Dec 14 15:56:23: Buy tramadol. from Buy tramadol.
Buy tramadol online save wholesale price yep. Buy tramadol online cod. Buy tramadol. Buy cheap tramadol mg tablets only in us online.
Mon Dec 15 01:52:09: Ephedra yellow swarm. from Original stacked ephedra.
Buy ephedra online drugstores yellow swarms. Ephedra attorneys california.
Mon Dec 15 18:35:54: Buy valium c.o.d.. from Buy c.o.d. valium.
Buy xanax valium online florida. Buy valium with mastercard. Buy valium c.o.d.. Buy valium. Valium online discount valium buy valium. Buy valium without prescription.
Tue Dec 16 04:37:26: Credit card rates. from Free porn without credit card.
Business credit card. Reducing credit card debt http.
Wed Dec 17 13:51:05: Tramadol. from Tramadol.
Tramadol.
Fri Dec 19 13:51:38: Cheapest tramadol available online. from Rxmedsasap com purchase tramadol.
Buy tramadol. Tramadol saturday delivery. Tramadol. Ultram tramadol. How much tramadol for daily use for dogs. Tramadol great buy. Hydrochloride tramadol.
Sun Dec 21 23:14:32: Casino royale. from Casino royale trailer.
Casino niagara. Casino royal.
Tue Nov 17 10:58:59: Pakistani cooking recipes. from Pakistani cooking recipes.
Pakistani cooking recipes.
Tue Nov 17 19:04:03: Cooking eggs in plastic ziplock bags. from Cooking without milk and eggs.
Cooking eggs in microwave. Cooking eggs in the microwave. Cooking eggs. Cooking hard boiled eggs.
Wed Nov 18 15:38:32: Tagtooga cooking food articles. from Cantonese cooking on find articles.
Tagtooga cooking food articles. Christmas cooking articles.
Thu Nov 19 04:41:04: Silicon cooking bags. from Silicon cooking bags.
Silicon cooking bags.
Thu Nov 19 07:05:26: Cooking oil as diesel fuel. from Cooking oil as diesel fuel.
Cooking oil as diesel fuel.
Thu Nov 19 21:08:21: Cooking without hydrogenated oils. from Cooking oils.
Healthy cooking oils. Cooking oils omega 3. Cooking without hydrogenated oils.
Fri Nov 20 04:05:24: Low cholesterol cooking. from Low cholesterol cooking.
Low cholesterol cooking.
Sat Nov 21 02:24:46: Irish cooking school. from Epicurean cooking school los angeles.
Irish-american pub cooking school. Rolling pin kitchen emporium cooking school. Flavor cooking school. Basic cooking school ca. Oregon cooking school. Le corp du bleu cooking school.
Sat Nov 21 12:35:14: Digital cooking thermometer. from Cooking thermometer.
Inaccurate digital cooking thermometer. Cooking digital thermometer. Sunbeam thermometer cooking probe.
Sun Nov 22 09:18:59: Simple campfire cooking recipes. from Campfire cooking recipes.
Free campfire cooking recipes.
Tue Nov 24 08:42:49: Fun thanksgiving online cooking games. from Free online cooking games.
Fun online cooking games. Cooking games for kids to play online.
Tue Nov 24 14:56:28: Cooking explained. from Cooking explained.
Cooking explained.
Tue Nov 24 19:58:18: Holland house cooking wine. from Information on cooking wine.
Sauterne cooking wine. White wine for cooking. Is cooking wine drinkable. Nutritional facts of cooking wine. Cooking with plum wine. Recovering alcoholic cooking with wine.
Wed Nov 25 05:22:43: Ready steady cooking show. from Ready steady cooking show.
Ready steady cooking show.
Sun Nov 29 01:39:08: Cooking yellow squash. from Cooking yellow squash.
Cooking yellow squash.
Thu Dec 03 00:48:46: Summer cooking jobs. from Arcata cooking jobs.
Oilfield cooking jobs northern alberta. Summer cooking jobs. Odd cooking jobs. Arcata cooking jobs. International jobs cooking.
Fri Dec 04 08:01:25: Cooking mussels. from Cooking mussels.
Cooking mussels.
Fri Dec 04 09:22:52: Blab tv pensacola cooking shows. from Wild game cooking shows.
Cooking shows jewish. Npr cooking shows. Cooking shows.
Mon Dec 07 00:12:01: Pressure cooking chicken. from Cooking chicken pot pie.
Cooking time whole chicken. Roast chicken cooking time. Cooking chicken in the oven.
Tue Dec 08 00:47:15: Tuscan cooking school. from Tuscan cooking school.
Tuscan cooking school.
Tue Dec 08 02:51:47: Essay on math and cooking. from Essay on math and cooking.
Essay on math and cooking.
Tue Dec 08 17:47:38: Cooking for a crowd menu amounts. from Cooking for a crowd menu amounts.
Cooking for a crowd menu amounts.
Tue Dec 08 19:52:56: Baking pork chops cooking time. from Baking pork chops cooking time.
Baking pork chops cooking time.
Wed Dec 09 12:02:45: French cooking bookshop. from French cooking bookshop.
French cooking bookshop.
Fri Dec 11 23:40:44: Cooking with marijuana. from Cooking channel.
Home cooking recipes. Cooking ham. Cooking turkey. Turkey cooking time.
Sun Dec 13 23:07:05: Cooking techniques for different types of meat. from Wok cooking techniques.
Mayan cooking techniques. Asia cooking techniques. Cooking techniques of asis. Cooking techniques for different types of meat.
Tue Dec 15 08:07:27: Cooking chitterlings turn black. from Cooking chitterlings turn black.
Cooking chitterlings turn black.
Wed Dec 16 01:57:58: Pbs cooking. from Pbs cooking.
Pbs cooking.
Thu Dec 17 02:09:21: King crab leg cooking instructions. from King crab leg cooking instructions.
King crab leg cooking instructions.
Fri Dec 18 04:02:04: Kitchen and cooking supplies. from Cooking supplies.
Looking for cooking supplies. Paris cooking supplies. Cooking supplies. Indian cooking supplies.
Sun Dec 20 07:22:00: Outdoor cooking equipment. from Outdoor cooking equipment.
Outdoor cooking equipment.
Sun Dec 20 12:12:57: Cabin cooking. from Cabin cooking.
Cabin cooking.
Mon Dec 21 09:10:41: Solar cooking projects. from Solar cooking projects.
Solar cooking projects.
Mon Dec 21 20:56:53: Portable cooking pit. from Portable cooking pit.
Portable cooking pit.
Tue Dec 22 15:43:45: Gas cooking stoves. from Gas cooking stoves.
Gas cooking stoves. Information on gas cooking stoves.
Tue Dec 22 19:43:36: Italy cooking school. from Giuliano bugiali s cooking school in italy.
Italy cooking school.
Fri Dec 25 18:10:38: Cooking steaks in the oven. from Cooking tenderloin beef steaks.
Cooking method used to cook steaks. Cooking temperature steaks. Cooking salmon steaks.
Fri Dec 25 22:20:22: Birthday cooking class in los angeles. from Birthday cooking class in los angeles.
Birthday cooking class in los angeles.
Mon Jan 11 08:23:52: Cooking beet greens. from Cooking beet greens.
Cooking beet greens.
Mon Jan 11 19:17:10: Cooking with marijuana. from Cooking with marijuana.
Cooking with marijuana. Marijuana cooking video by hans. Marijuana oil cooking recipe. Cooking marijuana.
Tue Jan 12 04:15:19: Cooking pumpkin seeds. from Pumpkin seeds cooking.
Cooking pumpkin seeds. Pumpkin seeds cooking.
Wed Jan 13 22:10:27: London broil cooking time. from London broil cooking time.
London broil cooking time.
Thu Jan 14 03:36:54: Brined turkey cooking time. from First time cooking a turkey for thanksgiving.
Cooking time for turkey. Turkey cooking time. Cooking bag turkey oven time.
Thu Jan 14 16:02:57: Paula dean s home cooking. from Paula dean s home cooking.
Paula dean home cooking.
Fri Jan 15 01:38:25: Victorian cooking utensils. from Victorian cooking utensils.
Victorian cooking utensils.
Fri Jan 22 12:04:56: Chinese cooking technique. from Chinese cooking lily.
Advanced chinese cooking courses. Chinese cooking vacations. Chinese manchurian soup cooking. Chinese cooking box. Differences in chinese cooking styles.
Sat Jan 23 09:31:39: Cooking crack cocaine. from Cooking crack cocaine spoon.
Cooking powder cocaine. Cooking crack cocaine spoon. Cooking crack cocaine. Cooking cocaine.
Sun Jan 24 17:58:30: Cooking butternut squash. from Cooking butternut squash.
Cooking butternut squash. Cooking tips butternut squash.
Mon Jan 25 18:48:00: Italy cooking classes. from Cooking classes in italy.
Cooking classes in italy.
Thu Jan 28 16:11:19: Cooking recipes from south africa. from Cooking recipes from south africa.
Cooking recipes from south africa.
Thu Jan 28 19:59:01: Cooking measurements conversions. from Measurements for cooking.
Cooking measurements. Cooking measurements conversions. Food and cooking measurements. Cooking measurements conversion chart.
Fri Jan 29 07:30:44: Cooking broccoli microwave. from Microwave rice cooking chart.
Microwave cooking cellular changes. Valentine microwave cooking.
Fri Jan 29 21:14:36: Barely cooking. from Barely cooking.
Barely cooking.
Sat Jan 30 09:55:02: Easy cooking for college. from Easy cooking for college.
Easy cooking for college.
Sun Jan 31 01:49:44: Substitutes for cooking oil. from Recipe substitutes for cooking oil.
Cooking oil substitutes. Substitutes for cooking oil. Recipe substitutes for cooking oil.
Sun Jan 31 05:53:41: Baking and cooking terms. from Dictionary cooking terms smear.
Important cooking terms to know.
Sun Jan 31 14:44:10: Cooking frozen crab legs. from Cooking frozen king crab legs.
Cooking frozen crab legs. Cooking frozen king crab legs.
Mon Feb 01 10:18:06: Islamists cooking children. from Islamists cooking children.
Islamists cooking children.
Mon Feb 01 15:45:30: Cooking turkey on camp fire. from Comedic duo camp cooking dvd.
Camp cooking job alberta. Camp out cooking. Camp cooking groundhog. Comedic duo camp cooking dvd.
Tue Feb 02 11:03:41: Diabetic cooking. from Diabetic recipes now your cooking.
Open directory home cooking special diets diabetic. Diabetic cooking. Amazon com diabetic cooking magazines. Diabetic recipes now your cooking. Diabetic cooking magazine.
Tue Feb 02 12:38:23: Cooking with semen. from Cooking with semen.
Cooking with semen.
Wed Feb 03 04:32:46: Hearth cooking. from Hearth cooking.
Hearth cooking. Hearth cooking utensils.
Wed Feb 03 15:45:31: Tips for cooking fudge. from Microwave cooking tips.
Turkey cooking tips.
Thu Feb 04 12:06:59: Dried beans cooking time. from Dried beans cooking time.
Cooking dried lima beans.
Thu Feb 04 16:01:37: Gas cooking stoves. from Information on gas cooking stoves.
Gas cooking stoves. Information on gas cooking stoves.
Fri Feb 05 02:16:14: Scandinavian cooking iron. from Scandinavian cooking show.
Scandinavian cast iron cooking. New scandinavian cooking dvd.
Fri Feb 05 11:01:36: Clay pot cooking a pork roast. from Clay pot and cooking.
Cooking with a clay flower pot. Clay pot cooking.
Fri Feb 05 22:38:45: Camping and cooking recipes. from Camping cooking recipes.
Camping recipes cooking. Camping cooking recipes.
Sat Feb 06 04:32:27: Kitchen and cooking clip art. from Clip art of cooking.
Free cooking and baking clip art. Clip art of cooking. Free cooking clip art. The art of fine cooking arvind saraswat. Men cooking clip art. Kitchen cooking graphics clip art.
Sun Feb 07 01:38:44: Cooking patty pan squash. from Cooking patty pan squash.
Cooking patty pan squash.
Sun Feb 07 10:14:24: Cooking with semen. from Cooking with semen.
Cooking with semen.
Sun Feb 07 19:47:32: Cooking beer brats. from Cooking brats.
Cooking brats in beer. Cooking beer brats. Cooking brats.
Sun Feb 07 20:33:43: Cooking steaks in the oven. from Cooking steaks in the oven.
Cooking steaks in the oven.
Mon Feb 08 00:25:13: Tagtooga cooking food articles. from Christmas cooking articles.
Tagtooga cooking food articles. Christmas cooking articles. Free cooking articles. Cantonese cooking on find articles. Newspaper articles solar cooking.
